If you don't subscribe to Entertainment Weekly, I heartily recommend picking up a copy of their "Best of the Decade" issue, which is currently on newsstands. There are several different covers included, but the real cover of the copies in the store is Johnny Depp. But that's not the best part.
Inside there are a few features. First is the top 15 entertainers of the decade, which, according to the EW staff, are...
* Johnny Depp (CAPTAIN Jack Sparrow)
* Beyonce ("If you like it, then you shoulda put a ring on it!")
* J.K. Rowling *ahem* Sorry abou' that. :P* Simon Cowell ("That sounded like cats jumping off the Empire State Building.")
* Tina Fey ("Bitch is the new black!")
* Justin Timberlake ("It's my dick in a box!")
* Peter Jackson ("You bow to no one.")
* Oprah Winfrey (Oh, how I love your inexplicable shouting of celebrities' names.)
* The
Sex and the City ladies ("My vagina's depressed!")
* Pixar's John Lasseter ("To infinity and beyond.")
* Will Smith (really?)
* J.J. Abrams (though I don't watch his biggest hit,
Lost, he had me at "Dear Sally")
* Steve Jobs (*hugs my Macbook and iPhone*)
* Meryl Streep ("Mamma mia ... here I go again...")
* Jon Stewart ("Stop hurting America.")
Then there's the "100 Greatest" stuff of the decade. Now, I braced myself, knowing that EW has had a regular Twilight column linked at the top of their website for well over a year now. The sparkle does make an appearance at #24, though not the franchise itself - oddly, the Team Edward / Team Jacob battle. But what's at number one? Ahead of "SexyBack" and the greatest
Buffy episode (which they give to "The Body," btw, not the musical) and
The Dark Knight and Jack Sparrow and
The Daily Show and the iPod and
Lost and YouTube and
The Sopranos and even the
Lord of the Rings movies?
It's this guy. (Also named Best Character.)
Twilight, meanwhile, in addition to the "Team [whatevs]" phenomenon, is mentioned alongside other vampire fiction (namely
True Blood and
The Vampire Diaries) as part of a more general vampire trend, in an editorial written by the delightfully irreverent Chelsea Handler. See what they did there? One franchise dominated a decade alongside (and in many ways ahead of) pirates and hobbits and snarky comedians and media moguls and cosmo-drinking Manhattanites and computer-animated toys/fish/rat-chefs/robots/monsters. The other is part of a current fad-of-the-moment.
I've gotten my back way up in the last year about all this sparkle nonsense. Now, I despise those books and have nothing but disdain for the movies (which are marginally better, I feel). But I have to confess that part of my vitriol was that Twilight seemed to be taking Harry's place in the cultural consciousness. That people were forgetting how amazing the Potter phenomenon was and still is. That those books - and to a lesser extent the movies - changed the fan-mania game in a way no series had since
Star Wars, and it's a game in which Twilight, for all its success, is but a mere player.
People can snicker all they want about them being kids books, and maybe a story about kid wizards isn't as "cool" as sexy vampires and werewolves, but Harry Potter was a Special Thing. Something that won't - and can't - happen again until something changes the game again in twenty or thirty years. I'm beyond proud to have been a part of it while it was still new and unfinished. To have been in the eye of the storm, as it were, fighting shipping wars and consuming spoilers and being ... if not
at the center, very near it. And most importantly, to have met all of
you because of it.
I realize it's just one magazine's perspective, but when you take a look at the past ten years as a whole, it's hard to ignore the enormous impact J.K. Rowling had. I look forward to seeing future generations fall in love with these books, perhaps not exactly as we did (since those little whipper-snappers will never have to wait for future installments - OFF MY LAWN, HOOLIGANS!). And, at the risk of sounding petty, I also look forward to the shame faces of former Twihards who look back on all this bedazzlement in twenty years and either laugh or cry at their own sparkle-steria. Seriously, laugh or cry - I'm not picky.
Harry Potter is still very much in my heart, and I'm convinced it always will be, even though I may think about it less and less as time goes by. *hugs all my Gryffindorks, Ravengeeks, Hufflepunks and Slytherdweebs*
ETA: Favorite quote from the JKR blurb - "She's said to be working on a new novel for children, but our guess is that the kids are gonna have to fight us for it." Damn right!